)
As 2024 progresses, Ukraine continues to grapple with the economic repercussions of the ongoing war with Russia, while U.S. companies operating in Russia have contributed significantly to the Russian economy through tax payments. In 2023, U.S. firms paid approximately $1.2 billion in profit taxes to Russia, an increase from $915.7 million in 2021. This figure highlights the complex relationship between U.S. businesses and the Russian market, as 123 large U.S. companies and around 328 total remain active in the country [2be3763d].
Among the top tax contributors are major corporations such as Philip Morris International, which paid $220 million, followed by PepsiCo at $135 million, and Mars at $99 million. This financial support has drawn criticism from various quarters, including Dr. Michael McFaul, who condemned U.S. companies for indirectly supporting Putin's war efforts [2be3763d].
In light of these developments, some companies, like Citigroup, have announced plans to wind down their operations in Russia, a move that reflects growing concerns over corporate responsibility and the ethical implications of doing business in a country engaged in military aggression [2be3763d]. Furthermore, the Russian government is set to increase the corporate profit tax from 20% to 25% in 2025, alongside an exit tax of 15% for companies leaving the market, which could further impact U.S. firms' decisions [2be3763d].
Meanwhile, Ukraine's economy is showing signs of resilience despite ongoing challenges. The Ukrainian government is actively seeking to confiscate approximately $280 billion in frozen Russian assets to aid in reconstruction efforts. Recent financial support from the International Monetary Fund (IMF) has also provided a crucial boost, with a disbursement of $1.1 billion to help stabilize the economy amid delayed U.S. aid packages totaling $61 billion [334fd5d0].
In stark contrast, Russia's economy has demonstrated remarkable resilience in the face of Western sanctions. President Vladimir Putin recently praised the stability of Russia's economy, claiming it has grown faster than those of the U.S. and major European nations since the 2022 invasion of Ukraine. Unemployment rates are reportedly at a record low, and Putin's message to the Russian public is one of endurance: 'We’re still standing.' However, some experts argue that this image of resilience is misleading, as inflation has risen despite the central bank's interest rate hike to 21% in October [b67557ea].
In December 2024, Russia recorded over $40 billion in revenue, marking the highest monthly revenue since January 2011 and a 28% increase compared to December 2023. Notably, oil and gas income surged by 33% in December alone, contributing to a 26% rise for the entire year [70e00b98]. Despite sanctions aimed at disrupting funding for the war in Ukraine, the Russian Finance Ministry reported that non-oil and gas revenues exceeded budget estimates, with government spending in December reaching a record 7.15 trillion rubles [70e00b98]. The 2025 budget allocates one-third of its spending to military needs, underscoring the ongoing prioritization of defense amid the conflict [70e00b98].
However, a recent analysis has revealed that Russia has secretly funded half of its war costs through forced loans from banks, totaling between $210 billion and $250 billion since 2022. This scheme, uncovered by Craig Kennedy, a former Morgan Stanley executive, indicates that Russia's military spending exceeds its oil and gas revenues. The official 2025 defense budget stands at $126 billion, while corporate debt has surged by 71%, now comprising 19.4% of GDP. High interest rates, exceeding 21%, are crippling regular businesses, and by late 2024, banks were facing cash shortages. Potential bailouts could cost half of the 2024 federal budget, highlighting the financial instability within Russia [c0be3d11].
As the conflict continues, the economic landscape remains fraught with uncertainty. The debt-to-GDP ratio in Ukraine has surged to 90.4%, and the energy sector has suffered significant losses due to Russian attacks. Nevertheless, Ukraine is pursuing EU membership negotiations, signaling a commitment to align with Western standards and practices [334fd5d0].
In a broader context, U.S. President Donald Trump has commented that the current state of Russia's economy indicates potential trouble for Putin, suggesting that worsening economic issues may push the Kremlin to negotiate. The Kremlin employs 'reflexive control' to shape adversaries' perceptions, indicating a strategic approach to managing both domestic and international narratives [b67557ea].